The Honest Company & the Perils of Predatory Investment Practices

Jessica Alba, Honest Company & Why Specialized Legal Expertise Matters

Jessica Alba’s Honest Company may be a billion-dollar brand, but buried investor clauses could leave her with just a fraction of its value—proof that even celebrity founders aren’t immune to the fine print.

For founders eager to secure funding, the excitement of high valuation or a big investment can lead to oversight of the fine print that often favors investors at the expense of the company’s creators.

The Honest Company is often praised as a startup success story, but behind the headlines lies a cautionary tale for founders. While the company’s growth has been impressive, it also highlights how investor-friendly legal terms can quietly strip value and control from entrepreneurs—legally, but unexpectedly.

Investor Terms That Shift Power Away from Founders

Venture capitalists are savvy negotiators. They routinely include provisions that protect their upside and minimize their risk. For founders, these terms can have far-reaching consequences. Here are the most common clauses founders need to understand:

1. Liquidation Preferences

• What It Means: Investors get their money back first—and sometimes double or triple their investment—before founders or employees see a dime.

• Impact: Even with a strong exit valuation, founders could walk away with little to nothing as Alba is at risk of.

2. Board Control and Voting Rights

• What It Means: Investors may gain seats on the board or voting powers that allow them to dictate decisions.

• Impact: Founders can lose the ability to steer their own company’s direction, including decisions around acquisitions or leadership changes.

3. Anti-Dilution Clauses

• What It Means: If the company’s valuation decreases, investors are issued additional shares to preserve their ownership percentage.

• Impact: Founders and employees face further dilution, cutting away at their stake.

4. Drag-Along Rights

• What It Means: Investors can force the company into a sale, even if the founders disagree.

• Impact: Founders lose control over when and how they exit.

These provisions, when layered across multiple rounds of funding, can turn into a “perfect storm” that leaves founders sidelined or undervalued in their own companies- like Jessica Alba is facing with The Honest Company.

How Founders Can Protect Themselves

The key to safeguarding your equity and control lies in understanding your leverage and working with specialists who can spot these traps. Venture capital deals are designed to favor those who draft the terms, and often that’s the investor. For entrepreneurs who are not yet versed in this unique language, Keiretsu can help you with this. 

To begin, here’s how founders can protect themselves:

1.    Know the Terms, Not Just the ValuationA high valuation can be misleading if paired with unfavorable investor rights. Look beyond the big numbers to terms like liquidation preferences and voting rights.

2.    Negotiate Investor-Friendly Terms

o   Push for 1X liquidation preferences instead of 2X or 3X.

o   Opt for non-participating preferred stock to limit investor payouts.

o   Ensure anti-dilution protections are fair and capped.

3.    Retain Decision-Making PowerSafeguard board seats and voting structures so that investors cannot push you out or block strategic decisions.

4.    Work with Venture-Specialized Legal AdvisorsFirms like Keiretsu Law specialize in identifying these hidden risks and negotiating founder-favorable agreements. Specialized attorneys know what to look for, what to push back on, and how to structure deals that support your long-term success.

5.    Strengthen Your Position Before Raising Funds

o   Achieve profitability or extend your runway to avoid desperation.

o   Attract competition between investors to gain better leverage.

o   Explore alternative funding options, like revenue-based financing or strategic partnerships, which limit dilution and maintain control.

The Honest Takeaway

Jessica Alba’s Honest Company is a reminder that success and growth don’t always mean fair outcomes for founders. Investor clauses, when overlooked, can legally tilt the scales and disintegrate what you’ve spent years building.

For founders, the most powerful tools are preparation, education, and expertise. By understanding the risks, negotiating wisely, and partnering with specialists like those at Keiretsu who can safeguard your interests, you can raise capital without sacrificing your vision or control.

Be meticulous with the Blueprint for your Future. With the right protections in place, your company’s success will reward you, not just your investors.

The foregoing has been prepared for the general information of clients and friends of the firm. This publication is distributed with the understanding that the author, publisher and distributor of this communication are not rendering legal, accounting, or other professional advice or opinions on specific facts or matters and, accordingly, assume no liability whatsoever in connection with its use. If you have any questions or require any further information regarding these or other related matters, please contact a designated Keiretsu Law representative. Pursuant to applicable rules of professional conduct, this communication may constitute Attorney Advertising.